Raise 4bet Issue

[Mr Tiger]

Two stats. Denominator is the same. Numerators are:

1) sum(if[holdem_hand_player_statistics.flg_p_3bet AND holdem_hand_player_statistics.enum_p_4bet_action='R', 1, 0])

2) sum(if[holdem_hand_player_statistics.flg_p_3bet AND holdem_hand_player_statistics.flg_p_4bet, 1, 0])

In the second case the value is greater, but for me they must be the same...

[WhiteRider]

holdem_hand_player_statistics.enum_p_4bet_action='R'
..is true when you face a 4Bet (or higher) and raise.

holdem_hand_player_statistics.flg_p_4bet
..is true if you make a 4Bet (or higher).

You can make a 4Bet without facing a 4Bet (specifically if you raise when facing a 3Bet) so I would expect the second value to be higher.

[Mr Tiger]

How can I make 4bet and 3bet in one hand without facing a 4bet?

[kraada]

Add AND NOT(holdem_hand_player_statistics.flg_p_4bet_def_opp)

That eliminates the opportunity to defend against a 4bet (or higher).

[Mr Tiger]

Adding this makes it zero in both cases.

[WhiteRider]

Please explain exactly what situation you're trying to count. You asked what the difference between your expressions is, and I explained, but without knowing what you're trying to count we can't help you build the "correct" expression.

[Mr Tiger]

I want to count times when a player raises after making a 3bet and facing a 4bet.

In the second case I can't make a 4bet not facing a 4bet because I've already made a 3bet. That's why, I think, both expressions must return the same value.

[WhiteRider]

Sorry, you're quite right - I had skimmed over the fact that you were making a 3Bet. In that case the expressions should be equivalent.
I don't see any differences in my database, but I don't have a lot of 4bet hands - if you can identify a hand, or a set of hands, where these are different please attach it/them to a Support Ticket so that we can check out what that is.